A third person thought his teeth looked “brighter than ever before,” and in agreement, an Instagram user wrote, “Hello new teeth! He looks great :).”

A netizen on X had a more detailed opinion on Depp’s pearly whites and stated, “Johnny Depp wears dentures now because his real teeth are clearly damaged. Or he probably got a tooth infection and had them all pulled.”

In the first video, Depp was also recorded sharing a meal with friends before posing with two fans by the same Sparrow artwork. The bartender, also known as Rap Rap Zoilo, uploaded the same video in a second Instagram post, but this one had extended footage.

In it, Zoilo talked to the celebrity behind the bar in the post that revealed their interaction happened at 1:41 a.m. in Exuma. The bartender also shook hands with the 61-year-old star several times, and Depp engaged with some patrons.